Skip to main content
Threat Level

Northern Ireland: government consults on extending non-jury trials to July 2029, citing the threat from terrorism and the persistence of paramilitary activity

The Northern Ireland Office opened a 12-week consultation on Monday 16 November. The provisions expire on 31 July 2027. The government's threat level page lists the UK level as severe and the Northern Ireland-related level as substantial.

16 Nov3 min read
Listen
Tap play to create the audio version โ€” it is then saved for everyone.
Northern Ireland: government consults on extending non-jury trials to July 2029, citing the threat from terrorism and the persistence of paramilitary activity
Ops Con Intelligence

The Northern Ireland Office (NIO) opened a public consultation at one minute past midnight on Monday 16 November on whether to extend the provisions that allow some criminal trials in Northern Ireland to be held without a jury. The government says non-jury trials have been necessary for a small number of exceptional cases because of the threat from terrorism and the persistence of paramilitary activity. This post is for operators and risk managers working in or into Northern Ireland.

What is new

The consultation document says the current non-jury trial provisions expire on 31 July 2027. The NIO is asking whether they should be extended for a further two years, to July 2029, and whether they should be changed in any way. The consultation runs for 12 weeks and closes at 5pm on Monday 8 February 2027. Responses go to the NIO by email or post.

What the consultation says

Under the Justice and Security (Northern Ireland) Act 2007, the Director of Public Prosecutions for Northern Ireland can decide that a trial should take place without a jury. That decision follows a strict statutory test and depends on the Director deciding there is a risk that the administration of justice might be impaired if the trial were held with a jury. An extension can only be for two years and needs the approval of both Houses of Parliament. The NIO says it wants views from the public, from bodies representing the judiciary and from community leaders across Northern Ireland.

Why the government says it is needed

The NIO says non-jury trials have been necessary for a small number of exceptional cases because of the threat from terrorism and the persistence of paramilitary activity in Northern Ireland. Its notes to editors say that in 2025 only 0.8 per cent of all Crown Court cases in Northern Ireland were held without a jury, that there is a presumption of trial by jury in every Crown Court case there, and it contrasts this with the old Diplock courts, where non-jury trial was the norm for certain offences. The consultation document puts the 2025 figure at eleven non-jury trials. The page adds that non-jury trials can also apply to certain cases in England, Wales and Northern Ireland under the Criminal Justice Act 2003.

The threat levels

The government's threat level page, read on 16 November, says the threat to the UK from terrorism is severe, meaning an attack is highly likely, and the threat to Northern Ireland from Northern Ireland-related terrorism is substantial, meaning an attack is likely. The page shows no date for when either level was set; it says the levels have no expiry date and can change at any time. The consultation document says the Northern Ireland-related level was lowered from severe in March 2024. The consultation does not change either level.

What it does not say

The web page itself names no case, group, incident or charge. The consultation document attached to it gives figures: 12 security-related shooting incidents and 18 security-related bombing incidents between 1 August 2025 and 31 July 2026, 24 casualties of paramilitary-style assaults and no security-related deaths. It asks two questions, whether the provisions should be extended for two years and whether they should be amended, and does not say which outcome the government prefers.

What it means for operators and risk managers

This is The Ops Con's reading, not the NIO's.

The value here is the source. A government department has stated, today and in its own words, that terrorism and the persistence of paramilitary activity are why non-jury trials have been necessary in a small number of exceptional cases, and its consultation document says many of those challenges still exist today. That is a useful line for a Northern Ireland risk assessment or a client brief, because it is dated, attributable and not a media summary. It is not evidence of a rising threat, and it should not be presented as one: the Northern Ireland-related level on the government's page is substantial, and the consultation document says it was lowered from severe in March 2024. For teams working there, keep the standing level in the assessment, watch for the consultation outcome and any Parliamentary vote on the extension next year, and treat this as context rather than a trigger for changed procedures.

Disclaimer. The Ops Con Intelligence briefings are compiled from open-source reporting and provided for situational awareness and professional development only. They are not operational, security, legal, financial or travel advice, and no reliance should be placed on them for any decision. Information may be incomplete, time-sensitive or change without notice โ€” always verify independently before acting. The Ops Con accepts no liability for any loss arising from use of this content.

Accredited & Recognised
SFJ Awards Approved CentreArmed Forces CovenantCPD Member #22285Insignia Awards Approved Training Provider